Good Morning Karachi (2013) Reviews

• badly acted with an unbelievable plot

  sumita_sinha2015-02-07

  The movie started with some promise with the older ladies, the mother and the neighbour, with some credible acting. But the main character spent most of the time with her mouth open, strutting awkwardly in heels and showing no acting skills what so ever. The plot involving fashion culture in Pakistan is not really believable, the main actor's context in the city of her birth and in her home is also so far fetched. The only believable thing is the death of Benazir Bhutto- a piece of history woven into the story- and this could have been such a powerful event to focus the storyline along with woman's emancipation but fails to do so. In the end, can't understand the story at all! Better to read the novel perhaps.

  More

• Simplistic

  Zarah_Bachchan2015-01-31

  The photography is very good, the story less so. Characters are not very developed. Rafina is portrayed as an innocent girl, but is actually quite vain. Also, the fashion industry is presented in a very naive manner as an empowering world. Although that it not the focus of the movie, heels and make-up are expensive, damaging, and rather oppressive too. The total rejection of social conservatism annoys me. Rafina will probably be happier being a model, but I'm not sure her example is scalable to the whole Pakistani society. Ultimately, the film sends a very individualistic message, and typically favors an oppression over another.

  More

• Go with the glow

  Prismark102018-01-26

  Rafina (Amna Ilyas) is a headstrong young woman who wants to do something with her life. She has a playful relationship with her fiance, Akram. Rafina's mother in law to be Rosie Khala, a beautician understands Rafina's frustrations and agrees to take her on as an assistant. Rafina may be a simple girl from the ghetto but she is tall and thin, she attracts the eye of some marketing industry experts who want a girl with wholesome looks. Good Morning Karachi is a radio station which gives ongoing news as the the film is set at the time of the elections in 2007 where Benazir Bhutto made her return to politics and was subsequently assassinated. The film is more than just Rafina wanting to make it big as a model although she soon realises that she will enter a world of vain, shallow rich people. The film is an unusual exploration of the role of young women in Pakistani society and also the frustrations that young men feel. Akram is happy with Rafina but then does not want her to work when they get married even though his mum has toiled for years working as a local beautician. In fact we are not really sure what Akram does but he turn out to be a political agitator who feels that the young have been betrayed with economic hopelessness. The irony is Akram is a Bhutto supporter, happy to help a woman to come into power but not happy for his wife to be have a career. The film is a study of ambition in a society where women are expected to know their limits whether it is because of conservative traditions or religion. It is a conflict Rafina faces but she also has an opportunity to make a better life for herself and her fatherless family. The script is not perfect, a lot of characters are not fully developed, the nuances of a lot of the arguments are not even explored, it is even clumsy at times. The film might even needed to discuss if the election of Bhutto would had many a difference Pakistan has been let down by its political elites who have been too busy lining their own pockets. Bhutto's own husband was widely mocked as Mr 10% when she was first in power. Still this is an interesting exploration of life in modern Pakistan.

  More

• Models vs Mullahs: A Dazzling Discovery from Pakistan that needs to be widely seen

  Barev20132014-12-01

  Viewed at the Innsbruck Film Festival, June 2014 ~ The first film of the second festival day, "Good Morning Pakistan", opened an entire new page on the poorly understood and highly maligned nuclear bastion of Islam, Pakistan, and introduces a fantastic new feminine screen presence, 23 year old Model turned actress AMNA ILYAS. We will no doubt be seeing more of her soon! -- Only 77 minute In length but so full of striking events and personalities that it seems twice as long. Director Sabiha Sumar applies Occam's Razor with unerring sharpness to a story that could easily have run three hours~~this is a film which must be seen far more widely! A dazzling discovery from a nation whose films are hardy ever seen outside of their home territory. Sumar Who learned her craft at elite American schools is a one woman wrecking crew trying to reestablish a film industry in her home country that was all but destroyed by the fanatic Islamic regime currently in power. In this startling picture the emerging fashion industry in Pakistan is set against the return to Pakistan and assassination of glamorous former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in 2009 as an English language radio station keeps the public informed with daily morning broadcasts of ongoing events. While basically fiction "good Morning Karachi" has the effect of a documentary revealing what is going on in one of the world's most dangerous countries. Among many other things, needless to say, a Powerful statement in favor of women's liberation in a country where "honor killings" are taken for granted and go unpunished. GMK is a not so distant cousin of the Barry Lewinson 1987 Robin Williams starrer "Good Morning Vietnam" -- equally critical of a corrupt regime but better! With this film alone my trip to the Alpine Paradise of Innsbruck was justified.

  More