Call Me Madam (1953) Reviews

• Broadway's greatest musical legend repeats her classic stage role!

  mark.waltz2004-07-16

  In her 60 year career, Ethel Merman only made two appearances in musical versions of her Broadway hits. The first was a much altered version of Cole Porter's "Anything Goes" in 1936, and the second was this striking and colorful musical, "Call Me Madam", by the legendary Irving Berlin. Ann Sothern and Lucille Ball were cast by MGM in two of her other Cole Porter hits, "Panama Hattie" and "DuBarry Was a Lady", while Betty Hutton was a second choice after Judy Garland to play Annie Oakley in "Annie Get Your Gun!". Over a decade later, Rosalind Russell was given her role of Mama Rose in "Gypsy". Fortunately, 20th Century Fox saw fit to cast Merman in the film version of "Call Me Madam", giving her a rare leading film role after they had cast her in supporting roles in movie musicals of the late 1930's. The Broadway hit had co-starred Oscar Winner Paul Lukas and Russell Nype, and for the film version, Oscar Winner George Sanders took over for Lukas, and Donald O'Connor, after his triumph in "Singin' in the Rain" and the "Francis the Talking Mule" films, replaced Nype. For the role of the Princess, originated on Broadway by Tamara Geva, Fox cast the pretty Vera-Ellen. However, the film is all Merman's as she sings, clowns, and bounces all over the fictional duchy of Lichtenberg. For the record, two small duchys of the time, Luxemborg and Lichtenstein, were combined into one to fictionalize the setting. The spoof of Pearl Mesta, American ambassador to Luxemborg, seemed appropriate for a musical, and Merman, after her triumph as Annie Oakley, was the perfect choice to spoof someone she actually knew. As Mrs. Sally Adams, Washington Hostess turned Ambassador, Merman turns the duchy upside down, and gets a charming lover in the process. George Sanders, usually cast as despicable villains (films such "Rebecca" and "All About Eve"), is cast against type, but is perfect with his suave charm. His villains also had charm in spite of their calculating manner. He also displays a fine singing voice, and does a remarkable job in spite of the fact that this is Merman's show all the way. As the younger lovers, Donald O'Connor and Vera-Ellen have some nice dance numbers, most notably "Something to Dance About", but the musical highlight is O'Connor and Merman's duet, "You're Just in Love". Merman shines in "The Hostess With the Mostess" and the interpolated "International Rag" (which replaced "Washington Square Dance" from the original show), while O'Connor almost tops his "Make Em' Laugh" number with "What Chance of I With Love?", an Irving Berlin song originally heard in the 1941 musical "Lousiana Purchase". The very charming and colorful "Ocarina" number gives Vera-Ellen her chance to shine, and is well staged in the confines of a movie camera. Berlin's lyrics are just as good as his "Annie Get Your Gun" score, and the book by Russell Crouse and Leland Hayward delightfully spoofed America's constant gifts of money to poorer countries. In fact, Merman has several comical phone conversations with President Harry S. Truman (who actually had left office by the time this film was released), and while the comments about Margaret Truman's acting career may seem dated, they become funnier with each passing phone conversation. In supporting roles are Billy DeWolfe as Merman's stuffy assistant, Walter Slezak as the Minister of Finance, Ludwig Stossel as the Grand Duke, and Lila Skala (later the head nun of "Lillies of the Field") who says not a word as his wife. Director Walter Lang did an outstanding job bringing the film to the big screen, and the dances by Robert Alton are outstanding as well. Every aspect of the film is done with care; costumes and scenery give the viewer a feeling of a more peaceful time in the world (even though it was less than a decade after World War II had ended), and some viewers might be reminded of the classic operettas being done on Broadway just a decade before. However, once Merman's vibrant personality takes over, there is no question that we are not in Sigmund Romberg territory; This is the Americana of Irving Berlin with brassy Merman, suave Sanders, rubber-legged O'Connor, and sweet Vera-Ellen. I first saw "Call Me Madam" back in 1982 at a summer classic movie retrospective where the audience applauded as if they were seeing a live performance. It turned up a decade later on cable with tons of commercials, but until the introduction of the Fox Movie Channel, it seemed to be one of those rare movies unavailable for viewing. Now it has also made its way onto DVD. Merman deservedly won a Golden Globe for her performance, but was sadly overlooked for an Oscar Nomination. Perhaps, like Carol Channing, she is too big for the big screen, and comes across better on stage. Still, she was neglected in films, and "Call Me Madam" will remain a vibrant and colorful record of what this great lady did best-to entertain and make the world forget its troubles. In some scenes, she can even tear your heart out. While her follow-up Fox film, "There's No Business Like Show Business", is enjoyable for what it is, it is "Call Me Madam" that gives her the biggest chance to shine on screen.

  More

• The Ultimate Ethel Merman Performance in a Movie

  darkinvader452102004-02-25

  I remember seeing Call Me Madam as a teenager when it first came out as a movie in 1953. There was the great Ethel Merman on the screen. I had never heard of her before as to who she was, but I saw the movie so many times that it is still very vivid in my mind. Always yelling "Hello Harry" every time the phone rang, when Billy De Wolfe tried to tell her that one of his jobs was to tell her how to dress, and she looked at him in his outfit with striped pants and quipped, "You're going to tell me how to dress? Your coat and pants don't even match!" But, the surprise of the movie was George Sanders singing especially his song "Marrying for Love". Who would have known that he had such a rich baritone voice. This was probably Vera Ellen's best movie including "Three Little Words" with Fred Astaire. She and Donald O'Connor were perfect in their dance numbers together. Ethel Merman's rendition of "The International Rag" was brassy and sassy the way only Ethel Merman could deliver it with the end of the song singing, "Oh, oh! Wiggle your personality!" and someone in the audience said, "She sure can wiggle it; can't she?" It was if as soon as you sat down to watch this wonderful musical, it was time to leave the theater. I understand that the film is finally going to be released on Video. It's about time. I'll buy one copy to look at and another to keep just in case. Wonderful entertainment. One of the best!

  More

• Merman, Like Olives . . .

  harry-762004-07-04

  is an acquired taste. Apparently enough folks developed it enough to keep Ethel's shows running for a couple of decades. One of the "Queens of Broadway" (with Mary Martin) Ethel Merman's brassy voice belted through many a record-breaking run, thrilling thousands. What a rare treat to see her in a role she made her own! "Call Me Madam" is a dandy musical, rich with a great Irving Berlin score and lively performances. Equally rare is the excellent singing performance of George Sanders. His beautiful baritone is heard in "It's an Old-fashioned Idea" and other lovely ballads. As he played Gen. Constantine, I couldn't help but wonder how his reported troubled private life might have gone had he done more light, musical fare. Sanders' whole demeanor is different: he's warm, relaxed, sincere and fun-filled--what a departure from the cynical cads he was almost always engaged to portray! [N. B. History shows he was signed to star in a stage production of "South Pacific," and his recording of solo ballads, "The Sanders Touch: Songs to the Lovely Lady"--released five years after this film--has become one of the hottest collectors' items around.] All I can say is, his singing is gorgeous in "Call Me Madam." If this Fox musical has the somewhat look and feel of an MGM production, there's Donald O'Conner and Vera-Ellen lending their aura from the latter studio. Director Walter Lang, an old-hand at Fox musicals and light comedies, keeps things on track, while Bob Alton's dances really hit-the-mark. "Call Me Madam" is a most delightful diversion, and a lasting testament to the gifted Merman--the "hostest with the mostest."

  More

• O'Connor and Merman Shine

  nmayers2004-05-11

  Both Ethel Merman and Donald O'Connor suffered from the same misfortune -- lack of quality movie roles to showcase their extraordinary gifts. In O'Connor's case, it was because from childhood up into his middle twenties he was contracted by Universal Studios which, up 'til that time, produced "B" movies, suitable for coming into an air-cooled movie theater on a hot summer's day, but not much else. He always shone brightly, however, even in those early films, but not 'til Singin' In The Rain -- and Call Me Madam -- did he get the chance to glitter in great "A" material. Ethel Merman, the greatest of the Broadway greats had expansive mannerisms, stereophonic lungs, and irrepressable exhuberance, and was not considered cinema material by the powers that be. See how wrong the powers can be? O'Connor and Merman together in this film make it great -- his dancing, her voice, their personalities blending in just the right way. Great movie with two great leads -- don't miss "Call Me Madam"!

  More

• Ethel's Finest Moment

  theowinthrop2004-08-24

  Carol Channing, Mary Martin, Ethel Merman - the three biggest stars of Broadway between 1940 and 1970, and none made as big an imprint in movies. This seems to be a running sore in cinematic history - so few stage stars were great film figures. Some, like George M. Cohan, did not like the restrictive effects of movie making, and made few stabs at film (though, fortunately, Cohan made THE PHANTOM PRESIDENT in 1932). Others just seemed to weak on film. The great Pauline Lord made one movie, the pathetic MISS WIGGS OF CABBAGE PATCH, which (if recalled at all) is remembered as a film "starring" (he was actually in a supporting role) W.C.Fields. Channing, star of GENTLEMEN PREFER BLONDS watched while that role went to Marilyn Monroe, and star of HELLO DOLLY watched as that role went to Barbara Streisand. Martin, star of SOUTH PACIFIC saw Mitzi Gaynor play Nellie Forbush, and star of THE SOUND OF MUSIC saw the role of Maria Von Trapp become identified with Julie Andrews. Merman with credits like ANYTHING GOES, PANAMA HATTIE, ANNIE GET YOUR GUN, and GYPSY, only was able to keep the role of Reno Sweeny in ANYTHING GOES, when it was first made into a film in the 1930s. She was fortunate to also have the role of Sally the ambassador in CALL ME MADAM on film. It was a rarity, because she knew the part and was able to shine in a film adaptation. It's success probably enabled her to get another lead in the musical THERE'S NO BUSINESS LIKE SHOW BUSINESS. But the latter film, despite her good work in it (and Dan Dailey's, Mitzi Gaynor, and Donald O'Connor's)is recalled because Marilyn Monroe sang "We're Having a Heat Wave". Merman never led in another musical film again, and would be overlooked for GYPSY (when Rosalind Russell got the part). At least here and in the first ANYTHING GOES we see how she handled stage roles in her career. Mary Martin was less successful, her film record of her stagecraft limited to the scene in the first Cole Porter biopic NIGHT AND DAY, when she sings the song MY HEART BELONGS TO DADDY as she did on stage (unfortunately two of her chorus, Gene Kelly and Van Johnson, were not asked to repeat their chorus boy parts). There is the television version of PETER PAN, which is on video. It's fortunate that exists (there is also some songs from SOUTH PACIFIC that were sung with Ezio Pinza on THE ED SULLIVAN SHOW). The rest is silence. As for Channing, the only time she appeared in a movie musical, it was as the wacky aunt of Mary Tyler Moore in THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE (a movie not based on any stage musical). Channing had little singing to do in it. So Merman was able to do one great performance on film. CALL ME MADAM, a musical spoof on the career of political hostess Pearl Mesta, was a charming little musical (no ANNIE GET YOUR GUN, though). It's best musical moment is the duet with Donald O'Connor (I HEAR MUSIC BUT I DON'T KNOW WHERE), and it is a romantic piece of fluff. Nice also to see George Sanders playing a decent chap for a change. But watching Merman at her best, makes one regret what was not captured on film of her other performances. Ironically, that great singing voice is best recalled as a "loud-mouth broad" voice from Merman's best remembered role: the obnoxious mother-in-law of Milton Berle in IT'S A MAD, MAD, MAD, MAD WORLD.

  More